Documents ‘Я’ Us

Remember when I had a gas leak?

Click above, or read it below in 66 dull words.

My gas meter was exchanged for a newer gas meter, a few days later there was a lingering strong smell of gas, I called a gas engineer out who located the source, a loose bolt that was little better than hand-tight.  He made the installation safe, and I made a complaint about the original installation, that the meter was left in an unsafe condition leaking gas.

The foul smell of box ticking

Today the person handling the complaint rang me. This is how the conversation went.

The systems thinking lesson

There are two realities in conflict here. One is the normal humdrum messy reality that you and me are in right now. The real one. This is the one where gas ignores tick-boxes and chooses to obey the laws of physics instead, leaking out to lower pressure surroundings where it can kill people.

Then there is the reality created and inhabited by the system that my complaint is enjoying.  In this reality you look at a piece of paper to find out what is and what is not the truth.

In this reality the truth is counted in tick-boxes and the truth is always counter-signed..

This reality is the unreality of a command and control bureaucracy. The unreality that is created when there is an audit or inspection or performance management regime. Wherever there is a control system that uses paper to control reality, the paper replaces reality.

The phrase “the map is not the territory”  means that the model you use to understand things does not replace those things, it is only a model and only useful in so far that it reflects reality and allows you to understand it and live in it usefully.

In these systems though the map always does replace reality.  There are distant planners, monitors and inspectors. Auditors and analysts. Managers and leaders.  All these people don’t experience the messy reality of work that happens a long way away from their desk, only the neat certitude of documents on their desk in front of them.

The man who rang me today saw his standard procedure and his checklist, the tick-boxes and the counter-signature. Logically me and my story cannot fit in with his. So am I mistaken or a liar? The subject never came up, and I doubt he considered it. We don’t have competing or contradictory realities, they run side by side without ever touching. When I said to him that the meter was left unsafe, this did not contradict the counter-signed tick-box checklist reality he is in. It was irrelevant to it.

In command and control bureaucracies the reality of documents replaces the real reality in so many ways:

Reality is never in a document.  It can never be understood through a document.  If you want to get reality you have to go to it. It won’t come to you, and it certainly never comes to you in Ariel point 12, double spaced.

This entry was posted in command and control, plausible but untrue, psychology and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Documents ‘Я’ Us

  1. Pingback: Five things to feed a hungry filing cabinet | thinkpurpose

  2. Pingback: How to do it | thinkpurpose

  3. Pingback: Paper Purpose | thinkpurpose

  4. Pingback: Lean, ISO and 6 Sigma all walk into a bar. Hilarity ensues. | thinkpurpose

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s